Guess How Many in the Jar
If you’re looking for a baby shower activity that’s quick to set up, fun for all ages, and guaranteed to get guests talking, Guess How Many in the Jar is a perfect choice. This classic game works with any theme, and it’s especially adorable for a Classic Bear or Polo Bear baby shower when you use small, themed items—like the teddy bear crackers (Teddy Grahams) shown in my example photo. It’s easy, interactive, and adds a sweet, polished moment to your table setup.
Disclosure: This page may contain affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
How the Game Works
Guests take a look at the jar filled with small items and write down their best guess for how many are inside. The person who comes closest—without going over—wins a small prize. It’s simple, fast, and doesn’t require any explanation, which makes it great for showers with mixed ages or larger groups.
What You Can Put in the Jar
Here are popular (and cute!) filler ideas hosts love using:
Food Items
- Teddy bear crackers (Teddy Grahams)
- Mini marshmallows
- M&M’s or Skittles
- Jelly beans
- Gummy bears
- Hershey Kisses
- Goldfish crackers
- Yogurt‑covered raisins
Baby Items
- Pacifiers
- Cotton balls
- Mini rubber ducks
- Baby socks rolled tightly
- Hair bows
- Washcloths rolled into tiny spirals
- Small wooden blocks
What You Need
- A clear jar (mason jar, apothecary jar, or any glass container)
- Your chosen filler items
- Guess cards or a small notepad
- Pens or pencils
- A small prize for the winner
- Optional: a themed sign to display next to the jar
Setup Tips
- Choose a jar size that fits your table and theme. Medium jars work best.
- Place the jar at eye level so guests can get a good look.
- Add a small sign with instructions to make the station feel polished.
- Keep the answer hidden—write the total on a sticky note and place it under the jar or inside an envelope.
- Use themed filler (like teddy bear crackers) if you want it to tie into your theme aesthetic.
Why Guests Love It
- It’s quick and easy
- No pressure or performance required
- Everyone can participate
- It sparks fun conversation and friendly competition
Why Hosts Love It
- Minimal setup
- Works with any theme
- Affordable and customizable
- Doubles as décor
- Perfect filler activity during mingling or gift opening
Prize Ideas
- Mini candle
- Coffee gift card
- Small spa item (hand cream, lip balm)
- Gourmet chocolate bar
- Cute bear‑themed item to match your theme
Sign Copy Ideas
Option 1 — Simple & Classic
Guess How Many?
Take a look at the jar and write down your best guess. The closest answer wins a prize!
Option 2 — Cute & Playful
How Many Are in the Jar?
Make your best guess and write it on a card. Closest guess (without going over) wins!
Option 3 — Classic Bear Theme
How Many Teddy Grahams?
Guess how many little bears are in the jar and jot down your answer. The closest guess wins a sweet prize!
Final Thoughts
Guess How Many in the Jar is one of those timeless baby shower games that always works. Whether you fill your jar with candy, baby items, or something theme‑friendly like teddy bear crackers, it’s a simple, charming activity that adds personality to your event and gives guests a fun moment to enjoy together.
For even more fun ideas, head over to my full roundup of baby shower games guests actually enjoy.
